The Marginalia ClubThe Marginalia ClubJoin
Back to community
The Marginalia
The Midnight Library
Matt Haig
Cover of The Midnight Library by Matt Haig
Reading Challenge

Unpopular opinion thread for The Midnight Library — bring your least defensible take.

By Priya Linden · The Midnight Library by Matt Haig

Between life and death, a library holds every life you could have lived. Spoilers are fair game below the first reply, so tread carefully if you're still reading.

Comments · 3,490

V
Vera Vance

Read it out loud to my partner in the evenings — highly recommend that way. The dialogue is doing about four jobs at once. One of my favourites from the archive.

❤️ 185

L
Louis Prewitt

I had to pause halfway through and just sit with it. Every scene has a door in it. Someone in chat pointed that out and I lost my mind. Thanks to everyone who posted here — made the read twice as good.

❤️ 225

C
Cora Ashcroft

Second read for me, and it's a different book the second time. Whoever flagged the recurring water imagery — thank you, I can't unsee it now. Bumping the author's backlist to the top of my stack.

❤️ 215

G
Grace Sterling

I had to pause halfway through and just sit with it. The prose does that trick where it's plain until suddenly it isn't. Would happily do a re-read discussion next year.

❤️ 186

R
Rosalind Vance

Read it out loud to my partner in the evenings — highly recommend that way. The dialogue is doing about four jobs at once. Already lent my copy out twice.

❤️ 176

A
Arthur Prewitt

I had to pause halfway through and just sit with it. Every scene has a door in it. Someone in chat pointed that out and I lost my mind. Five stars from me.

❤️ 215

W
Wren Kingsley

Read it out loud to my partner in the evenings — highly recommend that way. It's a quiet book with a very loud ending. Solid four stars, and a full five for the ending.

❤️ 185

C
Clara Sterling

I had to pause halfway through and just sit with it. The prose does that trick where it's plain until suddenly it isn't. Still thinking about that final line.

❤️ 215

T
Tamsin Nightingale

Second read for me, and it's a different book the second time. I loved how little it explains itself. One of my favourites from the archive.

❤️ 186

T
Theo Fairweather

I annotated so heavily the margins ran out. The pacing wobbles in the third quarter but the payoff earns it. Thanks to everyone who posted here — made the read twice as good.

❤️ 225

O
Oscar Hartley

I annotated so heavily the margins ran out. There's a generosity in how the author treats even the awful characters. Would happily do a re-read discussion next year.

❤️ 311

T
Thea Ashcroft

Second read for me, and it's a different book the second time. Whoever flagged the recurring water imagery — thank you, I can't unsee it now. Bumping the author's backlist to the top of my stack.

❤️ 261

T
Theo Fairweather

I annotated so heavily the margins ran out. The pacing wobbles in the third quarter but the payoff earns it. Thanks to everyone who posted here — made the read twice as good.

❤️ 311

T
Tamsin Nightingale

Second read for me, and it's a different book the second time. I loved how little it explains itself. One of my favourites from the archive.

❤️ 271

J
Jonah Sterling

I had to pause halfway through and just sit with it. The prose does that trick where it's plain until suddenly it isn't. Still thinking about that final line.

❤️ 301

D
Delphine Ashcroft

Second read for me, and it's a different book the second time. Whoever flagged the recurring water imagery — thank you, I can't unsee it now. Solid four stars, and a full five for the ending.

❤️ 311

M
Miles Pemberton

Finished this one in two sittings and I'm still turning the last chapter over. There's a generosity in how the author treats even the awful characters. Five stars from me.

❤️ 261

R
Rufus Nightingale

Second read for me, and it's a different book the second time. I loved how little it explains itself. Already lent my copy out twice.

❤️ 301

O
Oscar Rathbone

Finished this one in two sittings and I'm still turning the last chapter over. The secondary characters carry more weight than they get credit for. Would happily do a re-read discussion next year.

❤️ 271

C
Cora Ashcroft

Second read for me, and it's a different book the second time. Whoever flagged the recurring water imagery — thank you, I can't unsee it now. Bumping the author's backlist to the top of my stack.

❤️ 301